Occupy Wall Street: The First Quarter and Beyond

Dec 16, 2011

» Op-Ed, Huffington Post, by George Gresham

george_gresham_fa.jpgIn the world Wall Street has made, quarterly results are the measure of all things. And so, with the three-month anniversary of Occupy Wall Street just passed, it is, inevitably, time to take stock of the movement.

The results so far are impressive, only the most jaded cynic would deny it. Political leaders obsessed with the debt and deficits have been forced to focus on jobs and inequality. Tax breaks for the wealthy that were untouchable before September 17th are suddenly in the crosshairs of Congress. Giant corporations that pay no taxes are finally being called to account, and more progressive taxes are being promoted in Albany and elsewhere.

Still, the cynics can say that the tents are gone from Zuccotti Park and that the encampments across the country are disappearing one by one. In their eyes, Occupy Wall Street is just another sinking stock, one more bubble ready to burst.

Of course, this is why we need a longer time frame to appreciate the remarkable achievements and lasting promise of the Occupy movement. Like all of America’s great reform movements, Occupy Wall Street is attacking problems that seemed insoluble and uniting people who never realized they had interests in common. Students drowning in debt, workers without health care, retirees denied pensions, the unemployed of all stripes and party affiliations -- they’re all united now in a way they weren’t three months ago.

To those of us in the labor movement, it’s clear that Occupy Wall Street is doing what only the most tenacious organizers can: forging a way forward when progress seems impossible. Whether we formed our unions in the coal mines of Appalachia, the assembly lines of Detroit or the hospitals of New York, we recognize when the political and economic system is stacked against the working class and we recognize the enormous effort required to even the scales.

For decades, labor, the left and progressives of every stripe have warned about the scourge of inequality in America. It was Occupy Wall Street that finally jumpstarted a real conversation about how and why the richest 400 Americans have more wealth than the bottom 150 million combined.

gg_ows_fa5.jpg

Occupy Wall Street has reframed the national debate as quickly and dramatically as any social movement in American history. Before this Fall, America had no common language to explain the crash of 2008 and its causes. Now we can see and describe the chasm separating the 99 percent and the 1 percent. The Occupy movement might be mocked as naïve for lacking a specific set of demands, but they’ve brilliantly identified the one fundamental problem of our time.

gg_ows_fa4.jpgBecause Occupy Wall Street has drawn attention by marching across bridges and sitting down in streets, some critics call it a lawless mob. But Occupy’s peaceful protestors are firmly in the tradition of the civil rights movement. Having grown up in the segregated South, I understood that civil rights activists sat down at lunch counters not to break the law but to fix it. That’s what America’s real freedom movements have always done. Abolitionists, suffragists, gay rights activists, they’ve all pushed to reform the laws that betray America’s values.

We in labor know all about laws that need fixing. In our union, 1199SEIU United Healthcare Workers East, another movement born on the streets of New York, our hospital workers had to push beyond the bounds of existing law when they joined together a little more than 50 years ago. A loophole then in the nation’s labor law denied virtually all hospital workers the right to form unions. But the workers, many of them living in poverty, felt a union was their only way forward so they struck for fair wages and demanded recognition from their hospitals.

Hospital officials quickly condemned the strikers for their “revolution against law and order”—words that must sound familiar to Occupy protestors. During the strike, the hospitals conceded very little, and after 46 days the impoverished caregivers had to settle. Like the Occupiers forced from their encampments, the workers had to retreat from the streets and call survival a victory. Yet, after an intense advocacy campaign, hospital workers did win union rights in 1963 when Governor Nelson Rockefeller signed a bill granting collective bargaining rights to New York City’s hospital workers. After decades of organizing, the once-impoverished caregivers have become the bedrock of our city’s working class. We know that movements with humble beginnings can do great things.

Nevertheless, despite all the progress our members have made—expanding far beyond the five boroughs to unite with over 350,000 caregivers up and down the East Coast—none of us are insulated from the chill wind blowing through today’s economy. Nicole Owens, a medical assistant in Massachusetts, still has her job, but her husband can’t find work and now they and their three children are on the verge of eviction. In Florida, radiographer Jason Smith is also working, but his hours have been cut and now he’s facing foreclosure.

gg_ows_fa.jpg

America’s middle class is living on a knife edge and all of us need the Occupy movement to keep focusing Washington’s attention on that fact. For three months, they’ve done it when no one else could. Although many Occupiers are leaving their tents, if anything, their influence on community organizations, student groups and labor unions is only growing stronger. They’re reminding us of the hard-fought achievements of our past while giving us hope for the future.

Yes, the movement is fragile. No billionaire brothers are funding it. But the millions of Americans it’s inspired promise to make Occupy Wall Street as powerful, resilient and long lasting as any of the great American reform movements.


Showing 7 reactions


Carol Muise commented 2012-01-02 14:16:47 -0500 · Flag
I think the Union should get out of politics and refocus upon protecting workers rights at the workplace. Dues monies would be better spent protecting our healthcare and retirement benefits. Wall street is not alone in the blame for the financial collapse of 2008. Our government regulated the banks into giving mortgages to people who coundn’t afford them. How about we have an Occupy Barney Franks, Chris Dodd movement?
Raimundo Valdes commented 2011-12-27 10:39:04 -0500 · Flag
When a man stand up to save The nation’s moral, The dignity of The midle clase and demand for justice not for charity what in reality belong to us. That man it is called Naive.
The 99% movement is the voice of the nation, but when that voice have been ignored in one nation, Other nations will join to make that voice louder.
Notgrandfathersunion Seiu commented 2011-12-24 08:20:35 -0500 · Flag
Let me SHOUT this at you Mr. Gresham. The Unions are owned by corporations of corruption. The union brass seem to be calling for the righteous fight of collective bargaining. You know 1 voice for the betterment of all people. It sounds very nice and i’m sure it brings the new member dues as it should. But after the collective bargaining is over and the contracts agreed to, what happens then. What happens when a corrupt employer decides the contract dosen’t work for them and just blatant crushes employees. What will the union do for that person to protect him and his family. I will tell what SEIU local 1 Chicago did, they ran and hid. SEIU local 1 Chicago provided me with a union contract agreement and ran for the hills, or in this case it’s ran for the sewer………. As I begin, I think of the people of the Occupy Wall street movement, I think of all hard working people who have made this country great. I think of my Grandfathers struggle to bring the union to the coal mines of West Virginia. I hope and pray they accept me as one of their own and allow me to stand with them. GOD Bless You All.
For ten years I have been trying to expose the SEIU 1 Chicago Local Union for what I believe is fraud and corruption. I am attaching a copy of a SEIU Local 1 grievance form dated 15 May, 2002…Which I filed with the SEIU Union. I have marked this as (exhibit A) for your reference. The grievance written by union business agent John Zarris, states I have been required to work above my classification without being paid per the union contract, a contract which was agreed to between my employer, “Mid America management corp” and my union “SEIU local 1 Chicago”.
The complaint of the grievance was my employer required me to accept a 24 hour 7 days a week emergency call, required to respond within 20 minutes of page. Being in a Required Emergency call situation is NOT in the job description of my (Helper- A) classification as defined in the union contract.
After a six month wait, On 18 November, 2002 at my place of employment, I received a fax letter from SEIU local 1 union representative John Zarris. I am attaching a copy of this letter dated November 18, 2002. I have marked this as (exhibit B) for your reference…
The Fax from the SEIU 1 union representative John Zarris clearly states the union’s support of my grievance and states “should I have any problems with my employer regarding these matters, please call”. I was terminated within two hours of receiving this notification and the SEIU 1 union DID NOTHING to secure my job. It took Local 1 union rep John Zarris more than a week to return my many attempts and messages concerning my termination. On the phone with Union rep. John Zarris, I can’t explain my feeling when Mr. Zarris said “he was sorry for my termination, but there is nothing he can do to help me”. In shock, I said “that’s it! What am I supposed to do”, Mr. Zarris replied “Get yourself a good attorney” and ended the call. The SEIU refused any further contact with me.
I took the advice of union Rep. John Zarris and hired a Mr. Gary Abrams of Abrams and associate law offices, in downtown Chicago. After much money and many years later attorney Abrams informed me, I don’t have a case because I did not have a written agreement with “Mid America management corp”. Concerning my work responsibilities. I questioned attorney Abrams, “isn’t the union contract a written agreement”? Attorney Abrams informed me public policy takes precedent over the union contract, the level of proof needed, just wasn’t there, it’s a very complicated system” he said. The president of SEIU “Mary Kay Henry” was on television a few days ago. Mrs. Henry Stated “If one person has been taken advantage of, then we all have been taken advantage of” Mrs. Henry inspired me. I would like to let Mrs. Henry know it is now official, We have all been taken advantage of.

The attached grievance form and letter from the SEIU 1 union Chicago speaks volumes by their self. I did nothing wrong, I filed a legitimate grievance; SEIU agreed with me, my employer had done wrong. In the end I was terminated for filing this grievance, my termination was nothing more than outright blatant cold hearted retaliation by Mid America management corp. As for SEIU Chicago, they ran and hid. If the SEIU Chicago union won’t stand up and protect a dues paying member who the union knows to be in the right, then the question must be ask, Just who is the union protecting. During most of my eleven years of employment with Mid America management corp. the president of the company sat on the board of trustees Of the Chicago SEIU local 1 union. I believe this is a conflict of interests and speaks right at one of the big issue of our time, corporate power and influence, greed, fraud, corruption. I am speechless; this is not the union my Grandfather envisioned so many years ago. This is not the kind of union the members of SEIU 1 union deserve.

I realized the level of fraud and corruption in the Chicago SEIU must be rampant. I feel I must do something to stop what I believe is criminal action. If they will do this to me, I know they will do about anything to anybody. I wish the people responsible flushed out and dealt with in accordance with the laws of the United States of America. We as people must besiege fraud and Corruption and destroy it anywhere it is found and we must do this for each other. Over the years I have made countless attempts to bring this to the attention of the proper authorities, but either no one is listening or no one cares. I believe where there is smoke there is fire, I believe my situation is the smoke that marks a big fire of fraud and corruption in the SEIU Chicago union that needs extinguished in the worst way.
I hope my union brothers and sisters of the past understand this is not an attack on them or the precept of the union. I believe I am due clarification, I believe we are all due clarification, if for no other reason than ensure it never happens to anyone again. Please stand with me and demand answers.

Thank You and GOD Bless America
Michael Daugherty PLEASE SEE facebook(notGrandfathersunion seiu) or see Facebook(This is not my Grandfathers union)
Ira Wechsler commented 2011-12-20 19:10:11 -0500 · Flag
As long as the Occupy movement avoids the suicidal policy of tying the working class to electoral politics instead of fighting the bosses in the shops and communities.it will do fine. It must resist the overtures of the trade union leadership who are flag-waving patriots instead of working class warriors. Such leaders do not organize the full power of the membership on the streets to fight the bosses, instead they pose for photo-ops getting a 4 hour trip to jail to “prove” they have the workers interests at heart. II99 had less than 200 members at Foley Square last month, mostly paid staffers. Never sent the organizers out to the shops to bring out our 200,000 members in NY City and Long Island. Shame on you! They fear the grass-roots membership who are angry about hoispital closings and layoffs. Only for support of the political whores who are owned by Wall Street will our leaders mobilize. Shame on you!
Coert Bonthius followed this page 2011-12-20 13:33:27 -0500
Susan B. Anna commented 2011-12-20 13:07:00 -0500 · Flag
As far as I’m concerned the rising issues amongst the middle class will never be put to rest until everyone pays their fair share. The fact that I myself had to file for Chapter 13 because I couldn’t get the assistance needed from my very own union to pay off a debt and save my property from foreclosure still baffles me, and I pray that everyone caught in this “I can’t nor won’t pay taxes,” from the rich and congress itself will soon cease. You live in this state/country, you should pay taxes, no one should be exempt and no one should be able to find a loophole to get out of it. Stop milking the middle class and do what is only fair, pay your share…